Holden White, then 18, was throttled, had his wrists cut and neck sliced in a bathtub of bloody water in June 2020. The attack happened when he met Chance Seneca, 19, for a first date, he said.

Jeanne Menard is close friends with Holden White. "I was shocked, and I was really hurt by it," Menard said. She believes Seneca had a plan. "You can't just ask someone to come over then hurt them.