Redford, now 82, and Galifianakis, now 49, clearly resemble each other, and the internet is absolutely shocked to find out the popular meme is not ... think that the guy in this gif was Zach ...

In the mid-late twenty tens his face became an emblem of our surprise and disbelief at the world around us, as well as one of the most popular memes in the world. It lurked in niche forums online ...